Skip to ContentSkip to Footer

Why Your Home Might Be Ineligible for Insurance in Colorado


Are you one of the hundreds of people getting turned away from homeowner’s insurance or have had your insurance cancelled by your carrier? You’re definitely not alone, and there’s reasons for it!

Owning a home is a dream for many people, but when you live in a place like Colorado, where the beauty of the Rocky Mountains meets the allure of vibrant cities, there are some unique challenges when it comes to homeowners insurance. While insurance is essential to protect your investment and provide peace of mind, there are situations in which your home may be ineligible for coverage. Let’s dive into some common reasons why this might happen and what you can do about it.

1. High-risk locations

Colorado is known for its diverse geography, but it also means that some areas are more prone to natural disasters than others. If your home is in a high-risk location, such as a floodplain, wildfire-prone area, or avalanche zone, you might face difficulties in securing insurance. Insurance companies are cautious about homes in these regions because they face a higher likelihood of claims.

2. Age and condition of the home

The age and condition of your home can also impact your eligibility for insurance. Older homes, especially those with outdated electrical or plumbing systems, can be seen as higher risks. Insurance providers may be hesitant to cover homes that could have a greater chance of experiencing issues like water damage or electrical fires.

3. Lack of proper maintenance

Insurance companies expect homeowners to maintain their properties. If your home is in disrepair, with issues like a damaged roof, broken windows, or a crumbling foundation, it can be challenging to find an insurer willing to take on the risk. Regular maintenance and addressing repairs promptly can help keep your home insurable.

4. History of claims

Insurance companies consider your claims history when determining eligibility and rates. If you’ve made multiple claims in the past, especially for the same type of damage, insurers may view your home as a higher risk. This could result in higher premiums or even eligibility issues.

5. Hazardous materials

The presence of hazardous materials on your property, such as asbestos, lead-based paint, or copper wiring, can be a barrier to obtaining insurance. Insurers may require the removal or remediation of these materials before offering coverage.

6. Insurance score

Just as your credit score can impact your ability to get a loan, your insurance score can influence your eligibility for coverage. This score is based on various factors, including your claims history, credit history, and payment history. A poor insurance score can make it more challenging to find an insurer willing to cover your home.

7. Previous cancellations

If you’ve had a previous homeowners insurance policy canceled due to non-payment or other issues, it can be a red flag for insurers. They may be reluctant to offer coverage to someone with a history of policy cancellations.

8. Home-based business

Running a home-based business is common, but it can affect your insurance eligibility. Some insurance providers may not cover homes with extensive business operations, especially those involving hazardous materials or a high level of foot traffic.

9. Underinsured or over-insured homes

Insurance providers want to see that your coverage aligns with the value of your home and possessions. If your policy is significantly underinsured, it might not meet the insurer’s requirements. Conversely, having excessive coverage can lead to higher premiums and possible eligibility issues.

10. Ownership issues

Issues related to property ownership can also impact your eligibility for insurance. For example, if there are disputes over property lines, unresolved title issues, or unpermitted structures on your land, insurance companies might be hesitant to provide coverage until these matters are resolved.

What Can You Do If Your Home Is Ineligible for Insurance?

Facing insurance ineligibility can be daunting, but there are steps you can take to address the situation:

1. Work on home improvements: If your home is ineligible due to its condition, consider making necessary repairs and improvements. This might involve updating your electrical system, repairing the roof, or addressing any safety hazards.

2. Mitigate risks: If you live in a high-risk area, take steps to mitigate those risks. For example, if you’re in a wildfire-prone zone, create defensible space around your home and invest in fire-resistant materials.

3. Shop around: Different insurance companies have varying eligibility criteria and risk appetites. Even if one insurer turns you down, another might be willing to provide coverage. Shopping around and getting quotes from multiple providers is essential.

4. Address claims history: If your claims history is a barrier to eligibility, focus on avoiding further claims for a period. This can demonstrate to insurers that you’re taking steps to reduce risk.

5. Consult an insurance agent: Insurance agents have in-depth knowledge of the industry and can often help you find coverage even if you’ve been turned down by other companies. They can also provide guidance on improving your eligibility. Speaking with an insurance broker is best practice since they have numerous carriers to choose from and can most likely find you insurance where captive agencies can’t.

6. Consider state programs: In some cases, homeowners in high-risk areas may be eligible for insurance through state-run programs designed to provide coverage when private insurers won’t.

7. Be transparent: When seeking insurance, be honest and transparent about your home’s condition, any previous claims, and any other factors that may affect eligibility. Misrepresenting information can lead to coverage denials or policy cancellations.

Securing homeowners insurance in Colorado, a state known for its diverse landscapes and weather patterns, can be challenging if your property faces unique risks or issues. However, with careful attention to your home’s condition, risk mitigation, and persistence in seeking coverage, you can often find a solution that provides the protection you need. Remember to consult with insurance professionals who can guide you through the process and help you make your home eligible for coverage.

Read about how inflation could be affecting your premiums here!

Get A Quote

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Customer Reviews

Five stars!

Anna-Lee Marie
Anna-Lee M

Best place to buy insurance for ANY reason.

Alexander Dunhill
Alexander D

...always so quick to respond!

Alisha Walker
Alisha W

Service is always prompt.

Mike S.
Mike S

...we highly recommend them for your insurance needs.

Jan B.
Jan B