Skip to ContentSkip to Footer

Unraveling the Surge: Why Car Insurance Costs Are on the Rise


As American motorists find relief at the pump with lower fuel prices, another financial roadblock is emerging—soaring car insurance premiums. Recent data from the Labor Department reveals a stark reality: despite fuel costs dropping by almost 2% compared to the previous year, auto insurance rates have skyrocketed by a staggering 20% over the same period. This sharp increase far exceeds the rate of inflation, with insurance coverage rising six times faster than overall consumer prices last year.

According to Insurify, an insurance comparison shopping site, the average U.S. rate for full auto coverage hit $2,019 per year in 2023. This represents a 24% surge from $1,633 in 2022 and an alarming 29% increase from the $1,567 recorded the prior year. Even the cost of a basic policy required by states witnessed a significant climb, reaching $1,154 a year in 2023.

The Driving Forces Behind Rising Premiums

Several factors are converging to drive up the cost of car insurance, with lingering effects from the pandemic being a key player. The current landscape sees vehicles becoming more expensive and, consequently, pricier to replace. Inflation is fueling the rise in the cost of computer components and other parts essential for repairs.

Compounding the issue is a shortage of mechanics across the U.S., leading to prolonged repair times. This delay translates into higher expenses for insurance companies covering the cost of rental cars for customers while their vehicles are in the shop. Climate change is adding another layer to the challenge, contributing to more weather-related damages to vehicles, resulting in increased claims and subsequently, higher premiums.

Greg McBride, chief financial analyst at, notes that insurance companies are grappling with escalating medical, legal, and operational costs. The impact has been significant, with major insurance providers like Allstate responding to heavy losses by threatening to withdraw auto coverage in some states.

In December, New Jersey approved Allstate’s auto rate increases averaging 17%, and New York greenlit a 15% hike in response to the company’s losses. California regulators have allowed Allstate to boost auto rates by a staggering 30%, highlighting the severity of the situation.

States Bearing the Brunt

Insurify’s data points to New York as the state where drivers feel the sting of car insurance costs the most. On average, motorists in the Empire State shell out a hefty $3,374 per year for full coverage, translating to around $281 per month. The top 10 states grappling with the highest average annual premiums also include:

  1. Louisiana—$2,883 per year ($240/month)
  2. Florida—$2,694 ($225/month)
  3. California—$2,416 ($201/month)
  4. Colorado—$2,337 ($195/month)
  5. South Dakota—$2,280 ($190/month)
  6. Michigan—$2,266 ($186/month)
  7. Kentucky—$2,228 ($185/month)
  8. Montana—$2,193 ($183/month)
  9. Oklahoma—$2,138 ($178/month)

As drivers navigate these tumultuous financial waters, the surge in car insurance costs remains a significant concern. Understanding the factors at play is crucial for consumers and policymakers alike as they seek to address the challenges posed by the ever-evolving landscape of auto insurance.

With the insane price hikes to insurance premiums, we have the ability to shop your policies with a multitude of carriers to secure you the best price.

Get A Quote

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Customer Reviews

Five stars!

Anna-Lee Marie
Anna-Lee M

Best place to buy insurance for ANY reason.

Alexander Dunhill
Alexander D

...always so quick to respond!

Alisha Walker
Alisha W

Service is always prompt.

Mike S.
Mike S

...we highly recommend them for your insurance needs.

Jan B.
Jan B